I’m naked. My head is shaved. I’m running for my life between endless rows of small barracks, fierce barking dogs biting at my heels. I turn and look. Behind the dogs the same SS guards who shaved my head are chasing me. I know they want to catch me and throw me into the gas chamber. They are gaining on me. I keep running as fast as I can, but they keep gaining on me. I glance behind as one of the guards has raised his pistol and is about to strike me. I gasp for air, and find myself bolting up in my bed, a silent scream waking me from the recurring nightmare.
The barracks in the nightmare are the same ones I saw on a weekend excursion in the spring of my junior year of high school in Germany, when my father drove my family to Dachau, the infamous concentration camp in Bavaria. On the drive through the German countryside, he told us the story of how he liberated a concentration camp for Russian POWs that his reconnaissance tank battalion stumbled upon in its race across Germany during the war. The experience was horrifying for him. I could hear the emotion in his voice as he recounted the story.
What I saw at Dachau shattered my sixteen-year-old mind. Large empty rooms held the ghostly spirits of Jews standing naked while being showered with the deadly gas made in the building next to my high school. Nausea overcame me when I saw the brick ovens that were used for cremating the bodies. The little museum displayed the shoes, clothing, suitcases, pictures and other personal belongings of the murdered people. Hot tears of outrage and grief flowed down my cheeks. “Why,” I asked my father, “did the Germans want to kill the Jewish people? The Jews didn’t do anything wrong.” My father tried his best to explain to me about scapegoats and envy, jealousy and fear but it still didn’t make any sense.
I felt an inexplicable identification with Jewish people. Jewish history became my obsession. I read every book I could find on the subject of the Holocaust, such as Man’s Search for Meaning by Viktor Frankl, The Diary of Young Girl by Anne Frank, Night by Elie Wiesel, Survival in Auschwitz by Primo Levi, and many more. Even after all the reading I did and the people I talked to, I still couldn’t make sense of the hideous persecution of an entire ethnic group.
My family moved to Frankfurt, Germany in the fall of 1964 after my father received his orders to pack up and ship out. Frankfurt would be his last assignment as a brigadier general in the U.S. Army, before returning to his roots in academia.
It was a shock to leave the States right when our country was in the middle of a social revolution. The civil rights march on Washington, Martin Luther’s speech, the arrival of the Beatles, the protest songs, demonstrations against the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution in the escalating Vietnam War, JFK’s funeral—I was right there in the heart of the action, living with my family just outside of DC during freshman and sophomore years of high school. The words to Bob Dylan’s newly released album, The Times They Are a-Changin’ rattled around in my brain, bursting forth into song when I was alone in the shower.
That exciting world came to an abrupt end when my parents, my younger brother, John, and I boarded the ocean liner S.S. America. My four older siblings waved good-bye from land as we left port and steamed our way across the Atlantic to Germany.
We moved to a house outside of Edwards Caserne, the nearby army base located just beyond the city limits. My father was the assistant division commander of the area.
Our new home stood on a curving row of identical, square, beige buildings in an isolated enclave where the officers and their families were housed. All around us were vast, empty fields of weeds, wildflowers and wild asparagus plants that my mother dug out of the soil and added to our meals. An old, abandoned apple orchard hid me out of sight and earshot while I experimented with smoking Gauloise cigarettes and belted out with all my heart the soulful French songs I had memorized by Edith Piaf.
On the far side of the fields I could see the trolley tracks, my route to freedom into downtown Frankfurt.
Most of the city of Frankfurt had been leveled by bombs during World War II. The city was rebuilt with drab high-rise buildings devoid of architectural charm. Frankfurt became known as a banking center.
I liked to roam around the older sections of the city that had escaped the bombing, like Old Sachsenhausen with its narrow cobblestone lanes and colorful half-timbered seventeenth century houses on the southern side of the Main River. On the other side of the river in the Innenstadt I found Goethe’s house.
The weather in Frankfurt was usually overcast with frequent rain. The city looked gray and somber.
During the week, the school bus stopped in front of my house to pick up the kids on my street and take us to school. Frankfurt American High School was large, full of military brats from the surrounding army and air force bases.
The high school was located in full view of the IG Farben building, former corporate headquarters for production of the pesticide Zyklon B, used during the Holocaust in the gas chambers. Each day the school bus passed the sinister building, I felt a cold shiver run through me. I wondered why no one else on the bus seemed to notice or care.
The massive building complex sat atop a grassy knoll on the far side of a wide stretch of lawn that separated it from the high school. The ugliness of the building was mitigated by extensive trees, bushes, and flower gardens where I escaped during the lunch hour to talk about books, philosophy and the meaning of life with my friend, John O., a fellow misfit from AP English class.
While being a conscientious, hardworking high school student with top grades, I led a double life in Germany. Every chance I could get, I jumped onto the trolley near our house and left the American enclave to explore the intriguing world around me. Watching football and drinking beer with my classmates had no appeal.
My father told me about the post-war Nuremberg trials of Nazi war criminals. A continuation of those trials for less notorious war criminals had been relocated to Frankfurt a few years earlier and were still going on in 1965, during my junior year of high school.
Now that Jewish people had become part of my psyche, there was no way I was going to miss this historic event. The trials took place during the workweek. That meant I had to skip school and just hope I wouldn’t get caught.
On my first trip to the trials, the trolley conductor pointed out the window and said, “Fräulein, that’s city hall, the building you’re looking for. But it’s being used as a courthouse for the trials. Did you know it’s forbidden to go in there without a special pass?”
The trolley stopped in front of city hall, a nondescript, modern glass and brick building.
“Yes. I know that. What time does the last trolley go back to Im Klingenfeld Strasse?” I asked as I stepped down onto the pavement. I had to make sure I got home the same time the school bus stopped in front of my house. I didn’t want my parents to know I skipped school. That would mean big trouble. The general’s daughter is supposed to be setting a good example.
I got off the trolley and headed to the courthouse. I waited until the person watching the door was distracted and then snuck into the building and quickly made my way to the gallery where the rows of seats were filled with mostly middle-aged Jews.
A few people looked over at me briefly with questioning looks on their faces. I felt self-conscious because I knew some people might mistake me for a German fräulein with my long, thick braid down my back. After all, I was half Swiss. I made a point of whispering in clearly articulated English, “Hello. Is it all right if I sit with you?” The woman near me gave me a barely perceptible smile and, with her hand, motioned me to sit down next to her. I felt a sense of solidarity with the group.
There was a long wait. No one stirred. The room was deathly silent. Eventually some men filed into the courthouse followed by guards. I could sense the collective breath-holding of the people around me. I craned my neck trying to spot the evil, monstrous SS officers but didn’t see them. I just saw some ordinary looking men standing in the front of the courtroom in white shirts and dark pants. They looked like they could have been the guys who ran the grocery store on the corner or the hardware store. One of the men was slightly chubby with red cheeks, just like the man who took my ticket on the trolley.
But, when the first of them was called to take the stand, it slowly dawned on me that these harmless looking men were the monsters who had done heinous deeds at Auschwitz, the ones I had read about. I strained to look into their faces to see if I could recognize evil.
My mind began to spin with questions. How could these ordinary-looking people turn into such monsters, capable of pure sadism and cruelty? Did their wives and children know what they had done? Surely there must be some good Germans in this country, but how can I tell who are the good ones? What were the good Germans doing during the war? What makes a good person turn into a bad person? Could I become a bad person given the right circumstances? I’d rather die than hurt somebody. But do I really know that for sure?
Hours passed listening to witnesses describe horrific acts by the defendants. The woman next to me cried quietly into her embroidered handkerchief during much of the testimony.
The trial turned out to be mostly a visual experience for me. It was hard to hear the conversation all the way on the other side of the large courtroom. And when I was able to hear snippets of the interrogation, the legalese was beyond my comfortably conversational German.
I looked at my watch. I had to leave the courthouse so I wouldn’t get home too late and make my parents suspicious. I shook the hand of the woman next to me and said, with tears in my eyes, how sorry I was for her suffering.
I caught the next trolley in front of the courthouse. I looked at the ticket taker, the same one who looked like the SS guard on trial. I wondered if this ordinary-appearing man was capable of unspeakable cruelty, given the right circumstances. I looked deeply into his face. There was no way to tell. What was he doing during the war? Maybe he was a regular soldier, a young man just following orders.
I got off the trolley at Im Klingenfeld, and ran across the empty fields, arriving home out of breath, just in time for supper.
Though we’ve not met i feel like we are kindred souls. I consider myself, more like others have consider me an ‘honorary’ Jew, maybe because i was born on the lower east side and lived in Williamsburg Brooklyn. I’ve lived in Germany though much later than yourself and visited also visited Dachau. Also reading many of the mentioned books. I vaguely remembered the trail of Adolph Eichmann and the disturbing pictures shown on TV.
What can be gained from knowing about all this horror and evil in the world? There was also Raul Wallenberg (If u don’t know him Google his name) and so many others who resisted. Lets remember the resisters. Etty Hillesum, Sophi Scholl and so many more. Maybe great darkness brings forth great light.
We do indeed sound like kindred souls, Karl. Amazing. Did you see “Labyrinth of Lies” which won best foreign film last year? I saw it a couple of months ago. While watching the film, I realized I was there in Frankfurt at the exact time the story took place AND I was at the trial depicted in the film!! I was totally taken by surprise. Thanks for your meaningful comments. Erica
thank you for writing this, Erica.
love
susan
Wow… just reread for a second time. So glad you are sharing this. Most meaningful to learn of the different worlds you so beautifully step into. Find myself filled with many thoughts. One of the most profound experiences I had while directing and choreographing for the dance company I founded, Avodah Dance Ensemble was when I invited a German choreographer/dance therapist to spend a week with me in NYC (Spring 2001) as together we explored the theme of Forgiveness. We were both born in 1943. Her father was a Nazi. I’m Jewish and my father fought in WW II in Germany. I choreographed a number of pieces related to the Holocaust mostly inspired by poetry (Primo Levi… children’s poems in a collection I Never Saw Another Butterfly). Together Ulla and I explored how to relate to each other along with four dancers and a percussionist. Profound experience that totally impacted me as I realized how she carried a huge burden from growing up in Germany at that time. Thank you so much for sharing and I look forward to reading your earlier posts and your new ones! With a deep bow….
What a profound experience you had, JoAnne. Very moving.
Thanks Erica,
You are a courageous soul! Did you go more than once to these trials? Really amazing that you did that! Love,
Cathy
Hi Cathy. I went twice. The experience deeply affected my young mind.
Thank you for sharing your story, Erica. I learned more about you and your life and adventures and courageous curiosity which is still such an important part of who you are. I hope to order “The Hiding Place” as recommended by your fellow readers.
Dear Erica,
Thanks yet again for a wonderful post and lovely writing. You always seem to perfectly capture the tone and nuance of the age that you are sharing a memory from. I was 16 again along with you.
The only thing that I would say is an oversight is referring to people who practice the Jewish faith as being an “ethnic group”. Hitler’s propaganda machine so successfully promoted this misconception that we are still being influenced by that myth today. Moreover, Hitler killed all that he saw as misfits or from whom he wished to steal: the mentally-ill, disabled, homosexuals, the Roma people (gypsies), and on. He murdered 6 million people of the Jewish persuasion, and another 6 million others too.
I too was fascinated/horrified/terrorized by the Holocaust, having the war experiences of my father and his family being something that was basically swept under the rug. Survivors all, they had been persecuted for being something, ie, “jewish, that they were not. They were all practicing protestants. I think that not talking about the war was their way of being able to go on to live successful, highly positive, and productive lives in America and Canada, where the openness, and goodness of these countries—particularly in 1950 when my family arrived—was very healing.
Anyway, in college I majored in Political Science, with a Specialization in International Relations, and particularly was interested in political philosophy and the Nazi government. Thus my knowledge about the Nazi propaganda that influenced so many to look the other way and still echoes in our culture and modern-day marketing sales propaganda.
Every atrocity is accompanied by those seemingly “unaffected” turning a blind eye; every atrocity brings out socio- and psychopaths who delight in inflicting horror on others; every atrocity illuminates those who are brave and kind. I too have read all the wonderful books that you mention in your post. There is one more that I would like to add, that perhaps you haven’t had a chance to read. I have read it more than once and, for me, its message brings ongoing hope and joy that although we cannot change this realm of pain and suffering that we live in, we can always seek the light: The Hiding Place, by Corrie ten Boom.
Thank you so much, Linda, for your thoughtful and moving comments. Love, Erica
The Hiding Place has been one of my favorite books for decades; Corrie ten Boom being one of my heroes.
There is even a child’s version which I have gotten for my grandchildren.
Ricky, your sneaking into the trials doesn’t surprise me in the least!
When you and Susie and I were in school together you two were the most imaginative and daring of anyone any of us had ever known.
As I remember your darling mother, I have a feeling she encouraged all her children to take these great leaps of daring-do. Perhaps she even knew about your escapade…do you think?
I love your comments, Deane. Yes, I remember those days at Hampton Roads and the daring things we did…although, at the time, I didn’t think of them as particularly daring since I didn’t know any other way of being. Thanks for the tip about The Hiding Place. I’ll see if I can find it. Love, Rickie
What a wonderful story!
Wow, Erica, I can’t believe you went to the Nuremberg trials! Maybe the fact you couldn’t follow the talking heightened that sense of how “normal” these “monsters” looked. It must have left some impression!
and I forgot to say that my father’s tank unit was one that participated in the liberation of one of the camps (can’t remember which one). He had gruesome pictures.
That’s amazing the parallels in our stories, Benette. Even our fathers had similar stories. Maybe our fathers knew each other. My father was in reconnaissance in the 3rd Armored Division. And your father?
We took the SS America to Germany but way before you did–probably 1953 or so. We were also stationed in Germany, but near Nuremberg and Munich. I was the youngest, maybe 4-6 years old, so I don’t remember much, but I do remember playing in ‘bombed down’ houses. Thanks for your memories.
What a courageous act, Erica – to sneak into the courtroom! I also like your thoughts about the “Unscheinbarkeit des Bösen.”
Erica, you had my devoted attention from the first few words. Amazing story. I’m emailing you a bit of a connection. So well written. Anna
I was a young teenager in the Belgian Congo when news of the concentration camps came over shortwave radio, plus
photos. These black & whites were enlarged and exhibited inside the railroad station. Mother and I got on our bikes to see them. We never expected to witness, even remotely, such horror, even Mother who had lived through the occupation of Brussels in WWI.
We were among a few viewers shocked into silence by the incredible reality displayed in this town of 2,000 people. Never shall I forget the sudden remark of one Belgian woman, “And to think we have for years considered that Jesus suffered the ultimate.”
75 years later Israeli brutes perpetuate the monstrosity.
This was totally engrossing. I planned to wait to read it all, but found myself unable to stop reading.
Your writing was great. You have had such an amazing life — You definitely need to share all of these
experiences with your intelligent thoughtful view of each one. I love what a brave young person you were
to ditch school and sneak into the building to watch such a sobering “adult” piece of history. Amazing.
My father had some experience with this subject during WW II. He wrote a story about meeting his brother while they both under fire in the European Theater during the war, though assigned to different units. All 3 brothers were in that war. I wonder how their parents weathered that, rural Tennessee folks that they were,
Here is an excerpt from his story.
“It was snowing a little when you went outside. You remembered the frozen bodies stacked
up like wood outside of Mittelwihr, and you shivered away from what you were thinking.
You shook hands again and told each other, “Keep your head down.” Then you rattled away
on the road to your C.P.”
Thanks for sharing that story, Julia!